Marianne's Response

Failure at growing Echinacea

I live in Port Townsend technically in Zone 8 but I have a microclimate where I get a little warmer in the summer (can be 90° but only for several interspersed days-never more than 10 days) and sometimes cooler in winter (sometimes a week or more of freezing) than the surrounding areas. I have tried 3 or 4 different times to get Echinacea established in the Fall only to have them die over the winter. The area I planted them in is part sun and gets about 4 hours of mid-day sun. The plant catalogs say it survives to Zone 9 in the West and tolerates full sun to partial sun. What can I do to improve survivability? I really like the Fall-toned ones for Autumn interest alongside some Heucheras, an Anemone, and a deep-toned Spurge. Help!

Posted by Debbie Nighswonger on July 23, 2025

Marianne's Response

The key to growing this prairie perennial plant is good drainage and lots of heat. It is the wet that rots and kills them in the winter not the cold. These members of the aster family are also known for being short lived so if you keep them alive for 3 or 4 years consider yourself lucky. I suggest you grow them on a slope or raised bed and add some boulders around the base to absorb more heat. Now here is the hard part. This plant needs moist soil as it becomes established and die quickly if the soil dries out. Once the roots have grown down deep, they are drought tolerant. You can divide the plants every few years and don't worry about feeding them as they tolerate poor soils. In your cool, maritime climate Echinacea are a challenge to grow but the spectacular colors and upright form of these perennials make them worth the effort. Keep growing, Marianne Binetti P.S. You may have good luck growing them in a large container them moving the pot under the eaves of the house during the wet winter.